It certainly wasn't the most adventurous look on the red carpet, but Emma Stone's soft pink Valentino gown dotted with stars was the best kind of theme dressing for a girl who is starring in a movie musical dedicated to Hollywood with a song literally called "City of Stars." Her Tiffany & Co. necklace was especially beautiful and looked antique (but maybe wasn't) and her make-up was perfection.
We are enjoying a Mandy Moore-assaince, guys. She's back and she's not shilling "Candy" or married to Ryan Adams or Walking to Remember. This new and improved version is a Serious Actress and of all the plunging necklines and capes, this ethereal navy Naeem Khan gown was my favorite. She looks like a queen and damn if she doesn't always give good face.
It would be very easy for this Chanel gown to go wrong in less capable hands, but on Riley Keogh (Elvis's granddaughter, y'all!) it's so right! I'm in love with the sheer layered bodice and the tricks it plays on the eye, and the dress actually looks comfortable. She wisely accessorized with a red lip and no distracting jewelry to let the art of the dress do the talking.
Lily Collins was the night's designated pretty pretty princess in this delicate Zuhair Murad. It's a little figure skatery, but I can't resist it. The way the lace trickles away at the top is very pretty. I like the red lip with the pink gown (very Valentine's Day), but I do think the updo would be nicer if it was a chignon. A sleek bob may have been even better to modernize such a romantic gown.
Drew Barrymore's Monique Lhuillier gown looks like a silver phoenix rising from the ashes as interpreted by Stevie Nicks and I'm digging it. The silver beading looked spectacular on camera and of all the exposed-shoulder sleeved dresses, I enjoyed this one the most. It's a little bit Old Hollywood and a little bit rock and roll.
Priyanka Chopra is a PRO at red carpet dressing. I haven't seen her take a single misstep since she started walking the plank a couple years ago. She's great at evoking certain moods. At the Oscars, it was pure Old Hollywood glamour in a voluminous chiffon red gown; here it's a little bit sexy moody rock star and I love the pairing of this gown with a cleavage-skimming diamond, tousled hair and a deep berry lip that was perfect with her complexion.
Reese is very good at selecting deceptively simple gowns, pairing them with interesting jewels and perfectly walking the line of on-trend and timeless. Her butter yellow Atelier Versace gown seemed a little boring to me at first, and then after I saw the veritable parade of yellow gowns, its perfect construction and fitting grew on me. Her instagram has a great picture of the yellow diamond Tiffany necklace up close and it's to die for.
We have to give serious credit to Blake Lively, who managed to translate starring on a CW teen drama and in "The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants" into being a fashion favorite and the wife of Ryan Reynolds. Don't get me wrong, she's out there carving out a career for herself, but at the end of the day, her biggest successes might be her turns on the red carpet. She has a glamorous and dramatic style that I love, and this black and gold Atelier Versace gown would have looked silly and boring without her enviable decolletage and that perfect accessorizing of emerald cuffs. They are glowing like they're made of actual kryptonite, guys. Only drawback is that she kept having to pose with her hands awkwardly shoved in the pockets at an angle that no one would ever stand.
Sarah Paulson is always having fun with fashion, I feel, and has settled into a very good rhythm lately of knowing what works for her: modern, sparkly and a little edgy. This Marc Jacobs dress is a little bit Dynasty, a little bit Ziggy Stardust and every bit perfect on her.
Don't you feel personally robbed that we didn't get to see Gina Rodriguez perform some kind of shimmy tribute with Chita Rivera in this swingy beaded Naeem Khan gown? This was a great choice for her: a Marilyn silhouette and spectacular on her skin tone. Plus she's a truly nice person and fun on Instagram to boot!
Quite a few women opted for pantsuits (Pantsuit Nation, you guys!) but I was most impressed with the style and thoughtfulness of Evan Rachel Wood's homage to Marlene Dietrich. The cut of her Altuzzara tux is perfect, it's elegant and the message was fantastic: she wanted to show that if you don't want to wear a dress, you don't have to and to just be yourself.
Ruth Negga, star of "Loving," is a relative newcomer and I always enjoy when an ingenue comes out sartorially swinging. This Louis Vuitton is like Blade Runner couture, and manages to be very sexy while being very covered up. Her smokey eye and nude lip were a fantastic make-up choice, and she got to hear Meryl Streep mention her name in an Irish accent, so night = made.
Who else could pull off a sparkly Michael Kors dress in this particular shade of Big Bird yellow? Viola Davis showed us so many times, from the red carpet to the acceptance speech to her Meryl tribute, that she slays.
Controversial opinion ahead! For me, Olivia Culpo is best known as a former Miss Universe and ex of Nick Jonas, but she caught my eye in this painterly Zuhair Murad that calls to mind the murals of Diego Rivera or even the finely detailed works of Gustav Klimt. I saw someone else on the Internet hated it, but I like how it stands out and how perfectly her makeup complemented the overall vibe. It's a little Frida-does-the-Globes and I'm feeling it.
Gwendoline Christie, you guys. What a tall statue of a lady, so perfectly draped in this classic sheath. This is a look for which she'll have no ragrets.
Good, but not Best
I am digging the salmon pink on Angela Bassett, but I am not entirely sold on the flying nun effect of the sleeves/capes/wings. The woman is not aging though, and always looks like a million bucks.
I have a dream and it is to one day be able to crown Anna Kendrick my very best dressed. I love her, and I feel like we could be real-life friends and I feel like she tries really hard to knock it out of the park, but she doesn't have the power when she's at bat. This Vionnet is one of her better turns in a while and I love the Grecian draping and pleating. The color just feels off to me...a little too dishwater gray. In white or teal or violet, this could have easily been in my best list.
Brie Larson looks perfectly gorgeous in this very safe red Rodarte gown. It's borderline ho-hum...nothing to sing about, nothing to complain about. It's good.
I LOVE Issa Rae and "Insecure" is so fantastic, so I was excited to see her have an excellent first turn on the red carpet. Next time, I'd like to see a little more daring...maybe a pop of more color on the lips?
JLD can do no wrong, and I enjoyed the optics of her black and white mod George Chakras sheath. It's very in keeping with her overall style, and she always looks great, yadda yadda yadda.
Kristen Bell has been very "I'm a WOMAN not a child Frozen princess or TV teenager" on the red carpet lately. This sexy black Jenny Packham gown is good but the overall effect actually felt a little aging to me. I think it's the hair and accessories...maybe a touch more rock-n-roll needed here, or different earrings?
Precious Millie Bobby Brown of Stranger Things is poised to become the next Emma Watson, mark my words. Her demure Jenny Packham with age-appropriate sparkly sandals was elegant and yet girlish, just as it should be for a 12-year-old.
Sofia Vergara looked hot, like normal and was on trend, like normal and very sparkly, like normal. She's got the opposite problem of Anna Kendrick; she always hits home runs so I almost want her to zig into something extremely simple and architectural when I expect her to zag. My one note would be that her ponytail feels lackluster with this Zuhair Murad dress.
I was SO happy to see Tracee Ellis Ross win, and she looked super hot and classy in this Zuhair Murad, but I just was struggling with the hem. I wish it was either a little bit shorter or to the ground. This in-between length felt stumpy to me and she seemed to be having a slightly hard time walking in it, too.
Shouldn't Ever Be Boring, But Is
This is a special category for Winona Ryder, who was truly one of the biggest and most acclaimed actresses of the late 80's and 90's, was known to be stylish and favor cool offbeat vintage, and showed up looking fit and pretty but trapped in an incredibly boring Viktor & Rolf gown. Johnny Depp has a tattoo that says "Wino Forever" because of this woman's notorious hotness, people. She should be knocking us out with her fashions and I hope this is rectified quickly.
Close, but Not Quite
From the front, I love this ethereal and romantic lavender Vera Wang gown on Hailee Steinfeld. This shade is particularly gorgeous with her coloring, and it has a Juliet-like quality. BUT, what you can't see is that it also has a cape on the back and with all of these elements — voluminous skirt, cape, sheer high neckline, exposed shoulders with drapey sleeves AND diamond necklace at the collar — it's all a bit much. I'd remove one element, either the sleeves or the cape, and switch the necklace out for pretty earrings.
Let's be clear: I would HATE this on literally everyone else and maybe in future years, I'll look back on this moment in shame. But it's super on-brand for Janelle Monae and I couldn't 100% hate this custom Armani. It kind of feels like a dress that would be worn by Phyllis Neffler in Troop Beverly Hills, and that's a particular sartorial weakness for me. I'll allow it.
Part of me is like YASS KERI YASS for just going balls-to-the-wall in this late 70's-style Studio 54-ready Jacob & Co. ensemble and the other part of me is like, Girl this is the Golden Globes. Save this for New Year's or a disco-themed birthday party and come ready to slay when it's broadcast on national television. Also, I have an aversion to chokers, so the past year has already been very hard for me.
I LOVE the cut of this extremely classic (and very Jackie O) Prada, especially for a lady sporting a baby bump. You know she was comfortable! I'm even on-board for the citron color that looks good on almost no one. What keeps giving me pause is the slapdash embellishment that looks like fake snow or tinsel. I think if it had pearl embellishments on the cuffs and maybe at the empire waist and nothing on the skirt, I'd be fully in for this look.
Oh Nicole, this Alexander McQueen is so. much. look. It's a little Ginger Rogers, a little Oksana Baiul at the 94 Olympics, a little Tilda Swinton in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe — all people I deeply appreciate, but never imagined combined in one ensemble. Ditch the puffy sleeves and I'm in love, but as long as they're on there, I cannot fully endorse. I do appreciate her 20-year campaign to push the envelope, though. She rarely bores me.
Sienna Miller puts things together in very unexpected ways and sometimes it works and sometimes it really leaves you questioning everything. On first glance, I liked the easy sporty elegance of her cutout white Michael Kors gown paired with an unfussy ponytail. But, accessorized with a pearl necklace and black bow in her hair, it was a little bit country club bad girl and I was confused about how all of these elements work together to project an image.
SJP, like Janelle Monae, just kind of gets a pass for looks that would be truly bonkers if they were attempted by, say, a starlet emerging from Pretty Little Liars. But when she does it, it's the norm and I admire her sense of fun with fashion. A lot of media outlets tried to make it into a Princess Leia homage, which might have been unintentional but sweet. I like the ballsiness of wearing a Vera Wang wedding gown on the red carpet. If I could change anything, I'd soften her eye make-up a bit.
My husband pronounced this Prada dress on Jessica Chastain "Not a good look." It's weird because it's remarkably unremarkable. I can barely drum up an emotion about it, except the flowers are a little musty old lady looking.
Michelle Williams wore a lace curtain dress, surely sewn by Maria Von Trapp for Louis Vuitton, with a ribbon straight out of Moulin Rouge. I couldn't hate it and yet I did! It's interesting because if the dress were worn without the ribbon, it would truly be the biggest snoozefest and with the ribbon, it feels like it's trying too hard. She also has become so addicted to neutrals that it makes me crave seeing her in color.
Kerry Washington, always out here trying to shove Fashion with a capital F down my throat and never ever succeeding. I cannot endorse any element of this Dolce and Gabbana, from the Granny's doilies yellow lace to the visible black underpinnings to the stumpifying ankle-length hem to the faux Michael Jackson-style military decorations half-sash. I just don't understand how this arrives on the rack, she tries it on and is like "YES! This fits the faux self-appointed Coming to America royalty look I've been going for, with the added benefit of making me look short! I think I'll pair it with black lipstick and call it a day!!"
I kinda get where this Gucci gown is supposed to be going, with tromp l'oeil ruffles and accoutrements, topped with a very real bow at the waist. But yeah, I hate it. What may appear clever on the runway and in the larger context of a couture show does not necessarily translate to real world practical applications, and this is a case in which Felicity Jones just can't deliver on the art history joke. All of the elements are pretty and the colors are flattering to her English rose complexion, but the overall effect is trying too hard. And as you'll see, pink ruffles were as big at this year's Golden Globes as they were at Julia Roberts' wedding in Steel Magnolias.
I could maybe, maybe, maybe convince myself I don't hate Carrie Underwood's pink cupcake frills if it didn't have the entirely unnecessary cutouts. The silhouette is great on her, the color almost works, but the actual idea behind the look (let's make it so frilly and girly and then MODERN with cutouts) is lazy and makes Felicity's dress seem so thoughtful!
And not to be outdone, Zoe Saldana (also in Gucci) wore this straight-up chocolate box valentine dress that is like a redux of every dress she's ever worn. No woman has ever been as addicted to ruffles and ombre as Zoe.
My eyes couldn't really comprehend Sophie Turner's Louis Vuitton. The shapes remind me of those canvas sun shades they put over patios at breweries sometimes. It's a lot of abstract shapes tied together with a karate robe belt. It provoked me to joke to Sean, "I don't understand what I'm seeing. It's like there are....Hidden Figures." HAHAHAHA. I crack myself up.
Thandie Newton's sequin-splattered Monse gown reminded me of something they'd make Katniss wear at the Hunger Games tribute showcase, right before the sequins turn into real flames and Lenny Kravitz informs her that her bra also has bullets or something.
Jessica Biel is always trying to convince me she gets high fashion and I am so unconvinced. She seems like someone who is constantly saying to her stylist, "So they think this works together? Are you sure? You think I'll be Best Dressed? Ok, I guess I'll give it a shot," and then walks out of the house wearing an Elie Saab that appears to be 3 dresses in one. The flowers (are they even flowers or are they loofahs?) by far are the worst and most unnecessary detail. I also think the black trim on the slit in the skirt is unneeded punctuation.
Claire Foy's custom Erdem does absolutely nothing for me. It looks like a Dynasty dress that was rejected for being too dowdy. Imagine it without puff sleeves, but instead with long sleeves and minus the purple sash. Suddenly it works, almost! But the color, paired with her blonde tresses, is also washing her out.
I'm calling out for a hero to come in and save Anna Chlumsky from herself. She just fires bad shot after bad shot and I'm almost certain she's got a great figure but I wouldn't know it from this droopy Roland Mouret. I love a good draped dress, but a BADLY draped dress is a pox upon her house. This is Scuttle Couture, seemingly designed and thrown together by a seagull wielding a dinglehopper.